What Is Downside Protection

December 13, 2025



Share this article

Downside protection is an option we offer at an additional cost which ensures that your price per gallon will decrease should oil prices fall after you have locked in. If you choose to purchase downside protection when you sign a contract, and our daily posted price is less than the rate you locked in at on the day of your delivery, we will charge your account the lower rate.


In July of 2008, oil prices reached a high of $4.799 per gallon, and continued to rise. Many customers feared paying over $5.00 a gallon, so they began to lock in at the $4.799 rate. As the winter approached and the cold weather settled in, prices began to fall. By December, our daily discounted rate dropped to $2.599 per gallon. Customers who locked in during the summer were now paying $2.20 more per gallon than the customers who decided not to lock in, and many customers that requested fixed price contracts wanted to break their contract and get out of the deal.


As our practice has always been, we only offers fixed price contracts to those who request to lock in. We do not encourage or discourage our customers to sign a contract; it is your decision. We offer all of the options in the marketplace to our customers and we let you decide whether or not to lock in. And in every contract we send, there is the downside protection option which is our insurance program that lessens the financial impact to those who fear locking in at the wrong price.



If you are serious about protecting yourself against falling oil prices after you lock in, you should consider downside protection.


Recent Posts

Car carrier truck hauling blue cars on a highway under a clear sky
By Kyle Wall • September 25, 2026
Switching propane suppliers in Kennebunk, ME, is easier than you think. Learn the steps and contact Garthwaite Energy for local service. Get a free quote.
Orange utility truck with hose reel and hazard placards parked beside a white building
By Kyle Wall • August 23, 2026
Ran out of heating oil in Kennebunk, ME? Garthwaite Energy offers 24/7 emergency heating oil supplier service. Call now for fast delivery and expert restart help.
A person wearing work pants and boots placing blue protective gloves on a metal grate near a wooden wall and oil tank pipe.
August 14, 2026
Find a reliable Heating Oil Supplier in Kennebunk, ME. Garthwaite Energy offers automatic delivery and emergency support. Call today for winter comfort.
A person wearing a blue jacket carrying a large red gas cylinder on their shoulder outdoors.
August 3, 2026
Compare automatic vs. will-call residential propane delivery Kennebunk ME. Garthwaite Energy serves the area with flexible options. Call today!
heating oil delivery technician filling a home fuel tank
July 28, 2026
Compare fixed, floating, prebuy & price-cap heating oil plans from Garthwaite Energy, your Heating Oil Supplier in Kennebunk, ME. Get a free quote today.
A home heating oil delivery in progress.
March 9, 2026
Discover the benefits of heating oil delivery service in Wells, ME. Garthwaite Energy makes home heating convenient, reliable, and affordable.
Gas technician with blue cylinder, representing professional residential propane delivery.
March 3, 2026
Understand the importance of timely propane delivery in Wells, ME. Garthwaite Energy ensures your home has continuous access to safe, reliable propane.
December 13, 2025
Get insight into fixed price programs for heating oil and propane. Garthwaite Energy helps you lock in stable prices year-round in Wells, ME.
December 13, 2025
Discover if a fixed price plan is right for you. Garthwaite Energy explains the pros and cons of locking in heating oil and propane prices.